Arlington, VA – Logan Kolas, Director of Technology Policy at the American Consumer Institute (ACI), has expressed significant concerns about Virginia’s proposed addictive feed legislation. While the goal of protecting children online is commendable, ACI highlights critical flaws in the bill that may lead to unintended consequences affecting privacy, legal clarity, and consumer freedoms.
Key Takeaways
- Vague and Over-broad Definitions:
The legislation’s definition of an “addictive feed” lacks scientific specificity and nuance. The bill applies vaguely and risks misclassifying platforms like Yelp as “addictive,” despite no evidence supporting dependency akin to medically recognized addictions. - Inconclusive Scientific Basis:
Current research shows mixed and weak correlations between social media use and mental health issues. As studies, including a National Academy of Sciences report, reveal limited evidence of causation, ACI advises lawmakers to proceed cautiously to avoid policies based on incomplete data. - Privacy and Legal Risks:
The bill’s parental consent requirements could inadvertently expand data collection, exposing users to increased privacy risks and conflicting with the spirit of the Virginia Virginia Consumer Data Protection Act. Moreover, the legislation’s legality remains uncertain, as similar laws in California have faced significant legal challenges and injunctions.
Given the substantial uncertainties and risks highlighted, ACI urges Virginia lawmakers to pause the advancement of this legislation. Instead, they should await clearer legal outcomes from other states and more robust scientific findings on the relationship between social media and addiction. Thoughtful, evidence-based policymaking is essential to protect consumers without compromising privacy or legal integrity.
For media inquiries, please email [email protected] to inquire about the above content.
The American Consumer Institute is a nonprofit education and research organization. For more information about the Institute, visit www.TheAmericanConsumer.Org or follow us on Twitter (X) @ConsumerPal.