|

Consumer Protection Should Focus on Consumer Interests

Consumers suffering under the crushing load of debt deserve real protection, not a legislative workaround that could reduce choice and mistarget tangible harm. Fortunately, a regulation already exists which achieves much of this aim.  The 1996 Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) addresses consumer deception, it just needs enforcement.  

Debt relief services, including for- and non-profit groups like debt settlement companies, reduce debt by either reducing the principal or the interest, helping consumers manage the overload of debt owed.

These services are supposed to behave according to the TSR which contains rules on both deceptive and abusive practices. This includes disclosing information about the services such as the time allotted for settlement and creditworthiness disclosures, while also strictly forbidding upfront payment.

The best way to protect consumers is for rules and consumer protections to apply fairly across the debt relief structure. On the whole, debt relief services have been kept in check by the TSR for decades and they have been successful without legislation. Both the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Consumer Financial Credit Bureau (CFPB) use the TSR to protect consumers. To address any existing issues, lawmakers should focus on expanded enforcement.

The FTC reports that of all the lawsuits and settlements in 2024, they returned 93 percent of the money they collected to consumers who were harmed. And just last month, a court entered a judgment of $106.8 million against a debt relief company the FTC alleged had impersonated government agencies among other abusive acts that targeted vulnerable populations.

In 2019, the CFPB, which focuses on protecting consumers in the financial services industry, alleged a debt relief service had charged consumers unlawfully without ever providing the services they marketed. A court issued a final judgment of $25 million in restitution with $5M going to the CFPB’s civil penalty fund ultimately being paid out to victims.

The FTC and the CFPB already have significant warnings about what to expect from debt settlement companies, as well as credit counseling organizations. Even the Department of Justice has a web page dedicated to a list of reputable credit counseling organizations while the FTC maintains a public catalog of debt relief companies and people who have since been banned.

Growing concern over deceptive practices including debt relief services has also been a focus of the FTC under Chairman Andrew Ferguson. The FTC shows that their efforts have not been in vain. According to their own data from last year regarding credit services advance payments, the FTC Consumer Sentinel Network reveals that the median amount of loss decreased significantly. In 2025, there was $100.8 million in money lost, and as of July 2026 it was only $46.6 million. This is a significant decrease should it stay the course.

The FTC is not only going after unfair, abusive, and deceptive practices, but they have coupled that with consumer education by empowering the consumer to make the best decision for their situation.

The TSR already contains consumer protection that should be enforced to address all instances of harm.

Consumers who are deep in debt and looking for a way out should have the option to choose what is right for them. The rules that exist now are neutral and effective at protecting consumers from abusive practices—and they rightly cover both for- and non-profit organizations. Consumers should know that no matter what financial options they choose, someone has their back.

Leah Locke is a Policy Analyst with the American Consumer Institute, a nonprofit education and research organization. Follow Leah on X @leahmlocke

Share: