|

The Economic Standard: Let Patients Decide How Many Healthcare Providers Are Needed

One of the biggest problems in healthcare is too little competition, yet certificate-of-need (CON) laws intentionally limit new providers from entering the market. States often require new providers to justify to regulators a new hospital, surgery center, ambulance provider, or expansion of an existing facility before it can serve patients. Preventing new providers from offering care doesn’t protect patients. It drives up costs and wait times. States should repeal CON laws and let patients’ needs determine how many providers communities need.

CON laws were designed around the idea that limiting healthcare supply would prevent costly excess capacity, such as unnecessary hospital beds, facilities, and medical equipment. In practice, they give regulators and existing providers the opportunity to decide whether new providers should be allowed into the market. The Federal Trade Commission and Department of Justicehave repeatedly concluded that CON laws suppress competition, restrict patient choice, and impede innovation.

The problem is easy to see when a new provider tries to enter a market. In Kentucky, Grace Home Care, a home-health agency planning to serve Louisville’s Nepali-speaking community, sought permission to enter the market with workers who could communicate with patients in their native language. As part of the CON review process, existing providers can oppose an applicant’s entry, and Baptist Health Home Care Louisville did so. Kentucky regulators ultimately determined that there was no need for another provider, blocking both new competition and another option for patients.

Read the full article here.

Justin Leventhal is a Senior Policy Analyst for the American Consumer Institute, a nonprofit education and research organization that advocates for consumers through evidence-based analysis and data. Follow Justin on X @JustinLeventhal

Share: